Sea anemones (Actinia equina) show consistent individual differences in boldness and thoroughness but lack a behavioural syndrome

Behavioural syndromes are suites of behaviours that corelate between-individuals but the same behaviours may also show within-individual correlations due to state dependency or trade-offs. Therefore, overall phenotypic behavioural correlations must be separated into their between and within-individual components. We investigate how startle response duration (an index of boldness) and time taken to reject an inert item (an index of investigation thoroughness) covary in beadlet sea anemones, Actinia equina. Anemones took longer to reject a more complex item compared to a simpler one, validating this measure of investigation thoroughness. We then quantified between and within-individual correlations using a Bayesian analysis and an alternative frequentist analysis, which returned the same results. Startle responses decreased with anemone size while thoroughness decreased across repeated observations, indicative of simple learning. For each behaviour repeatability was significant but relatively low and there was no behavioural syndrome. Rather, the two behaviours showed a negative within-individual correlation in most individuals. Thus, boldness and thoroughness are unlikely to be under correlative selection and that their joint expression may instead be independent, in line with the general pattern that cross-contextual behavioural syndromes are comparatively rare. It now appears that this pattern may extend broadly across animal diversity.